If you’re only looking at the movement of the major stock market indexes, you’re missing out on what’s going on under the surface. A divergence in the performance of the biggest stocks by market cap, which have more influence over the index’s movements, and that of smaller stocks is a signal that trouble may be ahead. Eric Platt reports in the Financial Times:
On the tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite the figures are even more striking, with more than 1,300 stocks down 50 per cent or more from their highest level of the past year. And roughly 80 per cent of the more than 3,000 stocks on the exchange are off at least 10 per cent.
The relatively low correlation partly explains why some managers are struggling in a year when the S&P 500 has clocked a double-digit advance. Just five stocks — Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Tesla and Google parent Alphabet — have accounted for more than half of the S&P 500’s returns since April, according to Goldman Sachs estimates.
On days when the market has sold off dramatically over the past month and the Cboe’s Vix volatility index has jumped, S&P 500 stocks have moved in a tighter formation. But even then, quirks have popped up, including two weeks ago when the index slid but its biggest constituent — Apple — rose solidly.
“Right now the index moves are completely misleading to what’s going on below the surface,” Brian Bost, the co-head of equities derivatives in the Americas at Barclays said.
The sharp swings have intensified over the past two weeks. Goldman strategist Rocky Fishman has pointed to the extreme levels of option trading as one factor propelling stocks in such different directions. It is a fact exacerbated by what he called “non-fundamental stock trading”, an allusion to the retail traders who have piled into the market over the past 22 months.
Option volumes have surged in recent months, with the Options Clearing Corporation reporting a record November. Since the start of December, there have been two days when more than 50m options have changed hands in the US, a level breached fewer than 10 times in history, Bloomberg data showed.
Michael Wilson, an equity strategist with Morgan Stanley, warned clients of the bank this week that he expected the main indices would “basically [go] nowhere over the next 12 months”. In that scenario, he said their stock selection was of more importance than before.
“2021 has been a difficult year to trade despite the very robust returns for the major large-cap indices,” he added. “It seemed as though the stocks and styles favoured by the market one day would be very different the following day.”
Traders and strategists added that correlations could still pick up in the weeks ahead, given the Fed is attempting to burnish its hawkish bona fides. If monetary policy changes cause a jolt of volatility in markets, or should the Omicron variant begin to dramatically alter the global growth trajectory, it would result in the kind of trading behaviour when whole industries or indices move in lock-step, analysts said.
“No one knows what will happen with inflation,” Bost said. “In the next six months we could find out we are in a regime shift and correlations could go right back to 1, where people say we do need to get out of equities.”
Read more here.
