Young Research & Publishing Inc.

Investment Research Since 1978

Disclosure

  • About Us
    • Contributors
    • Archives
    • Dick Young’s Safe America
    • The Final Richard C. Young’s Intelligence Report
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
    • Dick Young’s Research Key: Anecdotal Evidence Gathering
    • Crisis at Vanguard
  • Investment Analysis
    • Bonds
    • Currencies and Gold
    • Dividend Investing
    • ETFs & Funds
    • Investment Strategy
    • Retirement Investing
    • Stocks
    • The Efficient Frontier
  • Investment Counsel
  • Dynamic Maximizers®
  • Retirement Compounders®
  • Free Email Signup

Can ESG Work Without a Bubble?

January 26, 2022 By Jeremy Jones, CFA

By studio marble @ Shutterstock.com

Can an investing model created to supply certain companies with easy money work when there isn’t a bubble in the market? That’s the suggestion of James Mackintosh in The Wall Street Journal, who says that in a bubble-less world, ESG investing won’t make the difference it intends to. He writes:

A full-blown ESG bubble would surely encourage investment in things that count as “good” ESG, especially low-carbon energy. Every other bubble in history has been accompanied by a corporate spending boom, whether on canals, railways, the internet or mines, as existing companies take advantage of cheap capital and new players try to supply investors with what they want.

History has another lesson: Bubbles give investors too much of what they want. The price then collapses. Investors who don’t flee in time lose big.

Another problem for ESG adherents is that without a bubble, the investing strategy doesn’t in fact encourage companies to do much more of what the investors want.

Here’s how ESG investing is meant to change companies: I sell my traditional fund and pour the money into a sustainable fund, which buys stocks with high ESG scores. Repeat with $3.9 trillion—as estimated by Morningstar to be following ESG approaches world-wide—and the price of the higher-scoring stocks should be pushed up and the lower-scoring stocks down.

A higher stock valuation means a company can raise money through new share issues at a lower notional cost, important when executives decide whether to go ahead with an investment. Marginal dirty projects (coal mines) should become unprofitable, and so be canceled, while marginal clean projects (wind farms) should get a lower cost of capital, become profitable, and so get a green light.

How it actually works is a bit different. ESG investing is failing to change the cost of capital by much, even as vast amounts of money claim to be managed in a sustainable way.

The companies that score best on ESG tend to have higher valuations for other reasons anyway. Big companies do better on ESG, and so do stocks that have the stable earnings and low debt that investors value more highly.

MSCI’s popular USA ESG Leaders ended 2021 with a forward price-to-earnings ratio about 6% higher than the broad index, a premium that rose rapidly during the year. It is higher than usual, but only in line with the average premium from 2012 to 2015, in spite of the gusher of ESG funds since then.

Such small changes in the cost of capital have only a minor influence on corporate investment.

Read more here.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

You Might Also Like:

  • Is there a Bubble in Socially Responsible Investing (ESG)?
  • Are Most ESG Funds Just Tech Funds in Disguise?
  • Why Mutual Funds and ETFs No Longer Work
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Jeremy Jones, CFA
Jeremy Jones, CFA, CFP® is the Director of Research at Young Research & Publishing Inc., and the Chief Investment Officer at Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd. Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd. was ranked #5 in CNBC's 2021 Financial Advisor Top 100. Jeremy is also a contributing editor of youngresearch.com.
Latest posts by Jeremy Jones, CFA (see all)
  • The Clock is TikTok-ing on Legacy Social Media Platforms - May 13, 2022
  • The Innovation Bubble Goes Bust - May 12, 2022
  • Institutional Investors Fall in Love with Oil, Again - May 12, 2022

Search Young Research

Most Popular

  • Don’t Throw Your Bond Portfolio Out the Window
  • You Can Do Better than Mutual Funds and ETFs with Your Cash
  • Will Market Prices Soon Be Meaningful Again?
  • FAANGS Fall Like a Ton of BRICS
  • RAGE GAUGE: INVESTOR CARNAGE—Losing Control of Your Money
  • The Truth About the S&P 500 is Finally Out
  • FRIEND OR FOE: Are You Investing with Time, or Against It?
  • Vanguard Wellesley (VWINX) vs. Wellington (VWELX): Which Fund is Best?
  • Junk Bond Yields
  • EV Stocks Have More to Lose than Most

Don’t Miss

Default Risk Among the Many Concerns with Annuities

Risk and Reward: An Efficient Frontier

How to be a Billionaire: Proven Strategies from the Titans of Wealth

Could this Be the Vanguard GNMA Winning Edge?

Cryptocosm and Life After Google

Warning: Avoid Mutual Fund Year End Distributions

Is Gold a Good Long-term Investment?

How to Invest in Gold

Vanguard Wellington (VWELX): The Original Balanced Fund

What is the Best Gold ETF for Investing and Trading?

Procter & Gamble (PG) Stock: The Only True Dividend King

The Dividend King of the North

You’ll Love This if You’re Dreaming of an Active Retirement Life

RSS The Latest at Richardcyoung.com

  • WATCHING YOU: Italy Deploys Stealth Social Credit System
  • Baby Formula Gone Missing?
  • Is Your Financial Advisor Hiding the Truth About ESG?
  • BUSTED BUDGETS: Families Can’t Afford Democrats’ Anti-Energy Regulations
  • PRICES SOAR: Diesel Shortage Could Cripple America’s Economy
  • Conflict Between Democratic Sovereignty and Transnational Progressivism (Globalism)
  • “The Great Object Is that Every Man Be Armed”
  • MARKET CHAOS: This May Take Time, Here’s How to Prepare
  • Chris Masterjohn Is One of My Favorite Researchers Worldwide
  • The Rolling Stones in France

About Us

  • About Young Research
  • Archives
  • Contributors

Our Partners

  • Richard C. Young & Co.
  • Richardcyoung.com

Copyright © 2022 | Terms & Conditions

 

Loading Comments...
 

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.