Young Research & Publishing Inc.

Investment Research Since 1978

Compensation was paid to utilize rankings. Click here to read full disclosure.

  • About Us
    • Contributors
    • Archives
    • Dick Young’s Safe America
    • The Final Richard C. Young’s Intelligence Report
    • You’ve Read The Last Issue of Intelligence Report, Now What?
    • Dick Young’s Research Key: Anecdotal Evidence Gathering
    • Crisis at Vanguard
  • Investment Analysis
    • Bonds
    • Currencies and Gold
    • Dividend Investing
    • ETFs & Funds
    • Investment Strategy
    • Retirement Investing
    • Stocks
    • The Efficient Frontier
  • Investment Counsel
  • Retirement Compounders®
  • Free Email Signup

Commission Free Trading Has a Price

August 23, 2022 By Jeremy Jones, CFA

By iQoncept @ Shutterstock.com

A study performed by professors from the University of California, Irvine found that there were vast discrepancies in the costs of using different online brokerages offering commission-free trading. Bloomberg’s Eva Szalay reports:

Last year, five US professors opened two brokerage accounts and placed identical orders to test an algorithm. The next day, one was down by $150. The other was up $12.

They discovered it wasn’t a one-time anomaly.

Over more than five months, the academics used their own funds to execute 85,000 trades in 128 different stocks and made what they consider an important discovery: They were getting significantly different prices to buy and sell shares, depending on which brokerage handled the trade. Extrapolating from the results, they estimate it costs small-time US investors as much as $34 billion a year, said Christopher Schwarz, the finance professor at the University of California, Irvine who wrote the study along with four colleagues.

The paper indicates there are hidden costs to the day trading that’s proliferated along with no-fee brokerage accounts. That’s because even though trades are funneled through a handful of wholesale market makers, including Citadel Securities and Virtu Financial Inc., the pricing can vary, according to the paper. And those small discrepancies can have a large impact overall.

“Brokers are getting very different execution quality at the same market center,” Schwarz said in an interview. “Based on the data, market centers have an incredible power over brokers.”

The overall cost figure is an estimate of what investors would save if their orders were executed by the best performing of the five brokers in the study instead of the fourth best. It estimates that some $20 billion of execution costs would be saved if trading costs were cut by 0.10%.

In their experiment, the professors placed their trades simultaneously with five different brokers, all of which offered zero commission trading. Only some of them had payment-for-order-flow deals with market makers, an arrangement that allows large trading firms to buy orders from retail intermediaries. Such arrangements have drawn scrutiny since the start of the pademic’s meme-stock frenzy because the interests of brokers and markers can be aligned, potentially at the cost of investors. But the study found it had little impact.

There was, however, a “very large variation” in prices achieved from buying and selling stocks at different brokers, with the execution of some trades costing 10 times more — as measured by the basis-point spread that was charged — when made through one intermediary than with another.

Out of the six market makers that handled the orders in the experiment, more than 60% of all orders eventually went to Citadel Securities and Virtu. A spokesperson from Virtu declined to comment.

Read more here.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

You Might Also Like:

  • Quantumscape Suffers Price Collapse
  • Free Trading Comes at a Cost
  • Big Banks Adopting Blockchain for Short-Term Trading
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Jeremy Jones, CFA
Jeremy Jones, CFA, CFP® is the Director of Research at Young Research & Publishing Inc., and the Chief Investment Officer at Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd. CNBC has ranked Richard C. Young & Co., Ltd. as one of the Top 100 Financial Advisors in the nation (2019-2022) Disclosure. Jeremy is also a contributing editor of youngresearch.com.
Latest posts by Jeremy Jones, CFA (see all)
  • Money Market Assets Hit Record High: $5.4 Trillion - May 26, 2023
  • The Mania in AI Stocks Has Arrived - May 25, 2023
  • The Wisdom of Sam Zell - May 24, 2023

Search Young Research

Most Popular

  • Preparing You and a Loved One for Thanksgiving
  • Young Americans Tighten Their Belts as Boomers Consume
  • Retirement Income: We All Want It, We All...
  • Israel and Hamas Conflict Spilling into World’s Oceans
  • How Low Can Home Sales Fall?
  • Coal Giant Shifting Focus to Green Metals
  • “Inflation Is Killing Me,” He Said, “No It’s…”
  • Biden’s Debt-Fueled Spending Binge and America's Credit Rating
  • The Power of a Compound Interest Table
  • What Do Plunging Metal Prices Say About Electric Vehicles?

Don’t Miss

Default Risk Among the Many Concerns with Annuities

Risk and Reward: An Efficient Frontier

How to be a Billionaire: Proven Strategies from the Titans of Wealth

Cryptocosm and Life After Google

Warning: Avoid Mutual Fund Year End Distributions

Is Gold a Good Long-term Investment?

How to Invest in Gold

Vanguard Wellington (VWELX): The Original Balanced Fund

What is the Best Gold ETF for Investing and Trading?

Procter & Gamble (PG) Stock: The Only True Dividend King

The Dividend King of the North

You’ll Love This if You’re Dreaming of an Active Retirement Life

Your Survival Guy: “Life on Main Street Hasn’t Been This Hard in a While”

The Importance of a Balanced Portfolio

Invest with Peace of Mind and Comfort

RSS The Latest at Richardcyoung.com

  • Evil
  • Are Investors Ready to Pounce?
  • Americans Spent Plenty on Black Friday, but in a New Way
  • Should Taiwan Worry about America’s Commitments to Ukraine and Israel?
  • Senator Warns of Terrorist Attack Risk
  • The Dutch Reject Mass Immigration and Globalization
  • PROTECT THE BORDER: Canadian Pigs Threaten American Farmland
  • Milei’s Promise to Dismantle Corrupt Peronist System Won Argentina
  • Florida Business Owner, Alfie Oakes, Refuses to Comply with Biden Vaccine Mandate
  • FDA Considers Withdrawing Approval for Popular Pork Antibiotic Over Cancer Concerns

RSS The Latest at Yoursurvivalguy.com

  • Are Investors Ready to Pounce?
  • Disney Signals Problems with the ESG Agenda
  • Biden Gave Americans 10 Years of Inflation in Only 3
  • Happy Black Friday
  • Which Jimmy Buffett Album Is Your Favorite?
  • More Americans than Ever Own Guns
  • Happy Thanksgiving!
  • Preparing You and a Loved One for Thanksgiving
  • The Next Ronald Read? Save Til It Hurts
  • Americans Don’t Think Inflation Is Over

About Us

  • About Young Research
  • Archives
  • Contributors

Our Partners

  • Richard C. Young & Co.
  • Richardcyoung.com

Copyright © 2023 | Terms & Conditions

 

Loading Comments...
 

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.