Do you ever wonder why the guys on TV are selling you gold if it’s so valuable? Why don’t they just pocket it for themselves? Some pretty good money is being made in the transactions they’re promoting, don’t you think?
With all that selling, there’s buying too. Like the bookie in Vegas, the gold guy is after the vig, or commission, from both sides of the transaction. He doesn’t really care if gold goes up or down. He just happens to be promoting the buy side on television. All the while, it’s quite possible he sees a line of sellers wrapped around the block outside his office.
You don’t want your portfolio managed by someone in the transaction business. You want to work with someone who has a fiduciary responsibility to you—someone who’s looking out for your best interest as required by law. An investment advisor is such a person, required by law to act as your fiduciary under the Investment Advisor Act of 1940.
Broker-dealers are not held to a fiduciary requirement. They are held to a less stringent suitability requirement. The difference between the two could fill an office from floor to ceiling with stacks of small-print legal documents. I’ll summarize it as follows: a fiduciary standard puts your interests at the heart of every transaction; a suitability standard might too, but is hard to prove when things don’t exactly work out as planned.
In January, the SEC released its “Study on Investment Advisers and Broker-Dealers” to Congress. The study was required by Section 913 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The report is 208 pages long, including pages upon pages of recommendations. I could have done it with one or two words.
With all the recommendations, there’s no clear vision about whether or not broker-dealers are going to be held to a stricter fiduciary standard. Why not hold them to the same standard? A simple recommendation should simply state that investment advisors and broker-dealers will be held to the same fiduciary responsibility, as stated in the Investment Advisor Act of 1940.
My advice is if you’re looking for portfolio management, stick with an investment advisor. Many brokers say they’re advisors. Ask if they’re held to the strict Investment Advisor Act of 1940. Better yet, ask for it in writing. Investment advisors will provide you with their form ADV-II. And that’s as good as gold.
Latest posts by E.J. Smith (see all)
- Your Survival Guy in Paris: Peking Duck - April 24, 2019
- Paris Update: Notre-Dame, Protests and Your Survival Guy - April 23, 2019
- How Many “Retirees” Will Keep Working?: Today’s Elderly Twice as Likely to Work than in 1985 - April 22, 2019